We aim to review the best sleep-related products on the market. If you make a purchase through one of the links on our site, we may earn a commission. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure.

Brooklyn Bedding SIgnature Review - Featured
Overall Score


Material Quality


Temperature Neutrality

Edge Support

Motion Transfer


Value for Money


  • Free shipping
  • 120-night trial
  • 10-year warranty
Overall Score


Get Deal

August 3, 2020

We’re all unique creatures with different needs, interests, likes, and dislikes. One would be hard-pressed to find two people who like the same cup of coffee, let alone the same sort of mattress. Yet, as you’ll see in this Brooklyn Bedding Signature review, this is the kind of company that loves a challenge. And Brooklyn Bedding certainly loves upping the ante with its mattresses.

No newcomer to our site, you can also find detailed reviews of all Brooklyn’s mattress models. However, we found that the Signature deserves a story of its own. Hence, our team jumped into their pajamas and tested, inspected, and gathered all the relevant info so we could present you with a balanced account in this Brooking Bedding Signature review

So grab your tailor-made cup of coffee and find out if this mattress has your signature on it.


From $599

Get Deal
  • Suitable for all types of sleepers

  • Suitable for hot sleepers

  • 120-night trial

  • Great for couples

  • Great combination of support and comfort

  • Some off-gassing (although the scent isn’t overpowering)

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Review


The world may just be a huge global village, but we still like products manufactured in our own country. This is what you get with the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress—an all-American manufactured product based on superior construction principles. What we found when we started researching and testing for our Brooklyn Bedding Signature review for 2020 is that this model offers five distinct layers for a truly luxurious night’s sleep.

  • Cover: The premium quilted top is this mattress’s first taste of luxury. It is 1″ of quality cotton that’s quilted with polyfoam padding. This cover layer is designed to withstand long-term use without developing impressions.
  • Comfort Layer: The first comfort layer adds two more inches to this Brooklyn Bedding hybrid mattress and is made of hyper-elastic TitanFlex foam. The perfect synergy of latex and memory foam, it adjusts to your body as you move. The fact there’s also an infusion of TitaniumGel is a godsend for hot sleepers and those who are allergy-prone since this layer provides an antibacterial effect.
  • Transition Layer: As we pressed on with our Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress review, we found that the transition layer adds another 2″ to this mattress. This layer is made of Energex, a high-density polyfoam that lends the sleeper both support and much-needed body contouring—without the dreaded “smothered by the mattress” feeling.
  • Support Layer: Around 961 individually wrapped Ascension coils add another 6″ to this mattress and provide the sleeper with controlled motion transfer and optimized support. Add TitaniumGel—a phase-change microgel infusion—and your body temperature will stay under control during the night.
  • Base Layer: The final layer is made of 1″ of very dense foam that ensures the mattress’s durability. It also serves as a sturdy base for the coils, providing them with the perfect bounce surface, reviews on the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress indicate.

Comfort and Support

As a company dedicated to those all-important details, Brooklyn Bedding makes sure to cater to various sleep styles by offering three levels of firmness. This not only widens the customer pool but also allows you to pick and choose the level of support your body needs.


As already mentioned, the company provides three levels of firmness for potential customers: soft, medium (which is also the best seller), and firm.

For the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Soft, our review determined that this version would be ideal for side sleepers. Scoring a 4 on the firmness scale (with 10 being firmest), the soft version of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature will provide side sleepers with the increased pressure point relief their sleeping position demands.

However, there will also be plenty of support, albeit of a gentler sort. Also, most side sleepers prefer to be slightly enveloped by their mattress, and the Signature Soft certainly delivers on that point.

According to any Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress review, the Medium is the best seller. This doesn’t come as a surprise as most of our team found this version very comfortable with plenty of support and pressure point relief.

The medium version of the Signature is the perfect middle ground for all sorts of sleepers since it scores a 6 on the firmness scale. You definitely won’t sink into this mattress, yet it won’t feel overly firm if you’re a side sleeper. This option is especially suitable if you and your partner differ when it comes to sleeping styles.

A review of the Brooklyn Bedding Firm Signature mattress unequivocally shows that this level of firmness, an 8, is ideal for back and stomach sleepers. This model is also suitable for people who need more lumbar support. However, if you have specific back issues, we advise looking at mattresses particularly designed for back pain.


A sleeper’s body weight plays a huge part when it comes to sinkage. Naturally, this also depends on the model’s firmness. However, thanks to the layers that make up this 11.5″ mattress, sinkage is minimal even if you’re on the heavier side and opt to purchase the soft Signature model.

Temperature Neutrality

With its superb design, our Brooklyn Bedding Signature review team found this mattress to be a great choice for hot sleepers. There’s plenty of airflow, which ensures the mattress stays comfortably cool even if you’re a hot sleeper. This great feature is mostly due to the pocketed coils in the support layer, which allow for great airflow.

You can also add more comfort in terms of temperature by opting to get a cooling pillow—the Brooklyn Bedding Luxury Cooling Pillow made our top 10 list of the best cooling pillows on the market.

Edge Support

We’re all familiar with that dreadful feeling of falling asleep near the edge and then waking up with a start because you have a feeling you were about to hit the floor. Nor is it nice to sit on the edge only to feel you’re likely to slide off. 

Well, what our team and other Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid reviews found is that this mattress provides very good edge support due to its coil layer. No, it doesn’t feel as safe and firm around the edges as a traditional innerspring mattress, but it will still do the job nicely. So even if you end up on the very edge of the Signature, you’ll still enjoy a restful sleep.

Motion Transfer

The same issues that plague customers when it comes to edge support often extend to fidgety bedfellows. If you’re a light sleeper and you were lucky enough to score a partner who tosses and turns throughout the night, then you need a mattress that will absorb most of the movement. 

Brooklyn Bedding Signature reviews show that this is a bouncy mattress due to the pocketed coils. However, because of the layers of foam, the majority of movement will end up being absorbed. Therefore, the Signature could be a real gem for couples.


From $599

Get Deal
  • Suitable for all types of sleepers

  • Suitable for hot sleepers

  • 120-night trial

  • Great for couples

  • Great combination of support and comfort

  • Some off-gassing (although the scent isn’t overpowering)

Durability and Maintenance

Product Lifetime

Every new purchase carries a certain risk, and that’s as true for mattresses as it is for a new set of coffee cups. The risk increases as the price climbs up, and even with an affordable mattress, you’re likely to spend several hundred dollars. 

What we found both in the available Brooklyn Bedding Signature reviews as well as in our own careful research is that the company provides a 10-year warranty that goes a long way in making the customer feel safe, valued, and protected.

Keep in mind, after purchasing your Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress, reviews indicate you also need to make sure you have the right foundation and frame. You can use a slatted foundation, but make sure you have sufficient middle support and that the slats aren’t more than 3″ apart. If you have semi-flexible slats, you’ll have to add a non-flexible foundation (a bunkie board) for additional support.

The company advises against using a wire semi-flexible foundation. Also, following other Brooklyn Bedding mattress reviews, Signature mattresses can also be used on metal foundations, as well as wood and metal box foundations or metal or solid wood platforms. 

All these things have to be taken into consideration as they’ll affect your mattress’s lifespan.

Considering the quality of materials used as well as the production methods employed, there’s no reason to think this mattress won’t last you a good long while with proper care.


As we already gave a detailed description of all the layers at the very start of our Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid review, you know that these layers are meticulously arranged, and the mattress shouldn’t be flipped.

However, Brooklyn does recommend rotating the Signature every 6–8 months. This is especially important if one of the sleepers is considerably heavier than the other since this will help prevent indentations.

If your mattress gets a stain, you can spot clean it with lukewarm water and mild detergent. Nevertheless, it may be best to invest in a mattress protector. 

Customer Service

According to most Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress reviews, the customer service is efficient, friendly, and forthcoming. Representatives strive to resolve any issues customers might have quickly and find the best possible solution for both parties.

There are several ways for you to contact Brooklyn Bedding:

  • Live support at 1-888-210-8751, which also lets you reach Brooklyn Bedding’s sleep specialists
  • Live chat support available on the Brooklyn Bedding website
  • Leave a message—a web form is available in the Contact Us section

Terms of Sale

Trial Period and Return Policy

Another plus with Brooklyn Bedding is the fact it offers a 120-night trial for all its mattresses. If you’re unhappy with your mattress, you can simply contact the company at [email protected]. Note that you must test the mattress for a minimum of 30 days before you can return the product.

According to information on their website and other Brooklyn Bedding reviews, you need to provide them with the package dimensions. In turn, the company will email you a prepaid shipping label. You can send the product back and there will be no additional cost to you.

However, if you buy sleep accessories from Brooklyn Bedding, please keep in mind that these need to be returned within 30 days of receiving the product.

Shipping and Delivery

Brooklyn Bedding provides free FedEx Ground Shipping to 48 states, excluding Hawaii and Alaska. Customers in Alaska and Hawaii should note that shipping starts at $125 per mattress and $45 for sleep accessories.

DHL is used to ship these products to Canada—with shipping costs starting at $250 for a full mattress or $65 for sleep accessories. You can expect delivery within 3–4 business days for all US purchases. Keep in mind that you can’t have items shipped to APO addresses.

Since Brooklyn Bedding went so far as to import a mattress pressing machine from Italy, you’ll receive your Signature hybrid mattress in a box.


As already mentioned in our Brooklyn Bedding Signature review, the company provides a 10-year warranty and will cover deterioration and defects in the structure of the polyfoam or latex. The warranty also covers splitting or cracking in the material, despite proper handling, and body indentations of 1″ or greater.


Depending on the size, and according to Brooklyn Bedding Signature reviews, the prices range from $599 for a twin Signature all the way to $1,249 for a Cal king. Bearing in mind the quality of the materials used, we found this mattress to offer great value.

Who Should Buy the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress?

  • Back, side, and stomach sleepers. Our Brooklyn Bedding review of the Signature pointed out that they offer three firmness levels, each catering to a particular sort of sleeper. The soft model is perfect for side sleepers; the medium can be a fantastic solution for back, stomach, and side sleepers; and the firm is best for stomach and back sleepers.
  • People looking for lumbar support. Due to its numerous layers and the particular combination of materials and coils, the Signature provides superb lumbar support.
  • People suffering from allergies. Due to the unique design and combination of materials, these hybrid mattresses are especially good for allergy sufferers since the mattress promotes an anti-bacterial sleeping environment.
  • Hot sleepers. Again, because of the coil design and the materials used in the mattress’s layers, the airflow is excellent, helping hot sleepers keep their body temperature neutral.
  • Couples. After completing our Brooklyn Bedding Signature review, the honest opinion of our team is that the Medium Signature is the perfect choice for couples. It caters to various types of sleepers, and there’s hardly any motion transfer despite the fact this is a fairly bouncy mattress.

Who Should Look Elsewhere and Why?

  • People who mind off-gassing. While the off-gassing from the Signature mattress isn’t toxic, it will take a few days for it to disappear completely.
  • People who favor foam mattresses. This is a hybrid mattress, and while it has layers of both foam and latex, it also has coils. As a result, there isn’t much of that gently sinking sensation one gets with a foam mattress.

Summary of Our Brooklyn Bedding Signature Review

There’s little doubt that the Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a high-quality mattress that’s also reasonably priced. However, knowing if this is the mattress for you (or not) will only become evident once you start sleeping on it.

The great news is that you get a 120-night free trial with Brooklyn Bedding, so you really aren’t exposing yourself to any risk. There will only be some hassle involved if you decide the Signature isn’t the “one and only” mattress for you. 

Consider your needs, compare them against all the facts presented to you in this review, and decide if the Signature might be your perfect fit.


Is Brooklyn Bedding good?

While it can be very tricky to respond to a query like this one because everybody has their own definition of “good,” objectively speaking, there’s nothing about the Signature that’s questionable.

The materials used are of superb quality, and the layers are carefully designed and aligned by master craftsmen to provide the best possible comfort and support. Furthermore, the company has an untarnished reputation since it began producing mattresses in 1995.

Is Brooklyn Bedding non-toxic?

According to our Brooklyn Bedding Signature review, as well as other available data, Brooklyn Bedding is non-toxic and uses foam that’s been CertiPUR-US certified. These products also have no chemical fire sprays nor any chemical retardants.