by Mira Rakicevic

The Best Innerspring Mattress in 2019
(Expert Guide and Reviews)

Here you’ll find everything you need to know when shopping for the best innerspring mattress!

Our team of experts tested 34 innerspring mattresses—13 traditional innerspring and 21 hybrid models, to be precise. Following a strict methodology, we handpicked the top 10 choices.

When reviewing, we focussed on the following criteria:

  • Comfort level
  • Quality
  • Trial period and return policy
  • Warranty
  • Price

Besides the top 10 list, we prepared an in-depth buyer’s guide to help you choose wisely!

The Top 10 Best Innerspring Mattresses

NO.
COMPANY
STATS
FEATURES
PRICE
Excellent spinal support
Amazing temperature regulation
Made of natural organic materials
FROM $1,199
Amazing temperature regulation
Great spinal support
Good motion isolation
FROM $549
Excellent spinal support
Very breathable
A bouncy feel
FROM $1,649
A reversible mattress
Great temperature regulation
Good motion isolation
FROM $149
Good temperature regulation
Great motion isolation
Good spinal support
FROM $180
Good spinal support
Excellent temperature regulation
Good edge support
FROM $79.99
Three firmness levels
Lumbar zone technology
Excellent edge support
FROM $599
Excellent temperature regulation
Four firmness levels
Great spinal support
FROM $1,049
Excellent temperature regulation
Responsive
Good edge support
FROM $895
Good motion isolation
Great temperature regulation
Good spinal support
FROM $549

The Top 10 Innerspring Mattress Reviews

1. Naturepedic Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Naturepedic

Rating: 9.5

  • Type: Hybrid
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • 10-year warranty
  • Price: $1,199–$2,499

On the Chorus Organic mattress, which is medium-firm, most sleepers can have a great night’s rest since it offers a nice balance of spinal support and pressure relief. Its support layer features individually encased coils, which keep a sleeper’s spine in a natural position.

On top of it, there’s a layer of micro coils that help the mattress contour to a sleeper’s body. In addition, a layer made of PLA, which is a plant-based material, provides some pleasant pressure relief. Nevertheless, this might not be the best innerspring mattress for all side sleepers since some of them might need a more cushioning mattress for their sensitive pressure points, such as the shoulders and hips.

The comfort layer also features wool batting, which improves the mattress’s temperature regulation since wool is a natural insulator. The cover is made of organic cotton, so it’s very breathable and soft to touch.

We have to point out that Naturepedic doesn’t offer many shopping perks, which is pointed out in more than one innerspring mattress review. It’s great that this pocketed coil mattress is covered by a 10-year warranty, but there’s only a 30-day money-back guarantee. What’s more, if you decide to return the mattress, you’ll be responsible for return shipping costs, which can go up to $400. 

PROS:

  • Excellent spinal support
  • Amazing temperature regulation
  • Made of natural organic materials

CONS:

  • Average motion isolation

2. Yaasa Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Yaasa

Rating: 9.2

  • Type: Hybrid
  • 100-night trial
  • Free shipping
  • 10-year warranty
  • Price: $549–$999

The Yaasa ONE mattress offers great value for the money. At a reasonable price, you’ll get amazing comfort since individually pocketed coils keep a sleeper’s spine in proper alignment. That’s exactly what you should expect from the best innerspring mattress for back pain. In addition, below the soft cover, there’s a layer of cooling infinity foam, which contours to a sleeper’s body.

This hybrid mattress is an amazing choice for hot sleepers since it regulates temperature very well. Besides the coil system that improves air circulation, the cooling foam in the comfort layer doesn’t retain body heat.

Since the Yaasa ONE mattress minimizes motion transfer, it’s a good option for couples. It’s great to know that your partner’s restless night won’t disturb your sleep. Plus, solid edge support allows you to use the entire sleep surface. We believe that all this makes the Yaasa ONE the best innerspring mattress under $1000.

PROS:

  • Amazing temperature regulation
  • Great spinal support
  • Good motion isolation

CONS:

  • One firmness level

3. Leesa Legend Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Leesa

Rating: 9.1

  • Type: Dual hybrid
  • 100-night trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Free shipping
  • Price: $1,649–$2,649

The Leesa Legend is the latest model by Leesa, and in a way, it’s an upgraded version of the Leesa Hybrid mattress. It features a dual hybrid system for improved support and pressure relief. In particular, there’s a layer of micro-pocket springs on top of the pocket spring base. Many of the best innerspring mattress reviews praise this new addition for making the mattress even more supportive.

As you probably already know, most coil mattresses have exceptional temperature regulation. Considering that this mattress features two layers of individually wrapped coils, it’s no surprise that there’s amazing air circulation.

The comfort layer features both memory foam and responsive foam. Thanks to this combination, the mattress will nicely contour to your body without letting you sink in too deeply. A soft cover made of organic cotton and merino wool also contributes to the comfort of this mattress.

The Leesa Legend, one of the best rated innerspring mattresses, is covered by a 10-year warranty, and it comes with a 100-night trial. Although its price is above average, it’s good to know that Leesa donates one mattress for every 10 mattresses it sells.

PROS:

  • Excellent spinal support
  • Very breathable
  • A bouncy feel

CONS:

  • Above-average price point

4. Dreamfoam Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - DreamFoam

Rating: 9.0

  • Type: Hybrid
  • 120-night trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Free shipping
  • Price: $149–$270

The Dream mattress by Dreamfoam offers exceptional comfort at a below-average price. The individually encased coils provide a sleeper with good spinal support in all sleeping positions. Therefore, this might be the best innerspring mattress under $500. Both below and above the coil system, there’s a layer of base foam and a cover with quilted foam. These foam layers nicely contour to a sleeper’s body, relieving pressure points.

What makes this mattress stand out from the competition is that you can easily reverse it. Since you can sleep on both sides of this bed, its lifespan will be much longer.

Another advantage of the Dream mattress is that it doesn’t retain heat. The foam layers are very breathable, while the coil system allows for good air circulation. No wonder it’s often recommended as the best innerspring mattress for hot sleepers.

However, since the mattress has a pretty thin comfort layer, most side sleepers won’t be satisfied with the amount of pressure relief. Instead, they should look for hybrid mattresses with a more cushioning comfort level or memory foam mattresses.

PROS:

  • A reversible mattress
  • Great temperature regulation
  • Good motion isolation

CONS:

  • Not cushioning enough for most side sleepers

5. Zinus Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Zinus

Rating: 8.8

  • Type: Hybrid
  • 100-night trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Free shipping
  • Price: $180–$260

The Zinus Quilted Top Spring mattress is an amazing budget-friendly option. Even though it features a simple design, it offers good spinal support and nice pressure relief. That’s why it’s one of the best rated affordable innerspring mattresses.

The support layer uses iCoil technology, meaning that the coils are individually wrapped. Therefore, the mattress performs pretty well when it comes to motion transfer. It’s also good at regulating temperature since the coil system improves natural air circulation.

A layer of comfort foam is there to provide a sleeper with some contouring and cushioning. While it effectively relieves pressure points, some side sleepers might need a softer sleeping surface offering a deeper hug.

Even though Zinus mattresses are made in China, they use only CertiPUR-US® certified foam. It’s also great to know that this top rated innerspring mattress comes with a 10-year warranty and a 100-night sleep trial.

PROS:

  • Good temperature regulation
  • Great motion isolation
  • Good spinal support

CONS:

  • Not an ideal mattress for side sleepers

6. Linenspa Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Linenspa

Rating: 8.7

  • Type: Innerspring
  • 30-night trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Free shipping
  • Price: $79.99–$149.99

Linenspa sells budget-friendly mattresses, and even though they are not luxurious, they are pretty comfortable. The Linenspa innerspring mattress will allow you to have a great night’s sleep on its simple construction. Put simply, it’s one of the top rated budget innerspring mattresses.

Its core consists of tempered steel coils, which provide excellent support, keeping your spine in perfect alignment. A quilted foam cover offers some pressure relief, but it’s not very cushioning. Since the mattress is on the firm side, it’s best suited to stomach and back sleepers. Side sleepers will need a sleeping surface that offers more contouring.

Since the Linenspa innerspring mattress doesn’t feature thick layers of memory foam that tend to retain body heat, it has excellent temperature regulation. However, it’s definitely not the best rated innerspring mattress when it comes to motion isolation. Therefore, we don’t recommend it to couples, especially if one of the partners is a light sleeper.

PROS:

  • Good spinal support
  • Excellent temperature regulation
  • Good edge support

CONS:

  • Too firm for side sleepers

7. Saatva Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Saatva

Rating: 8.6

  • Type: Dual hybrid
  • 120-night trial
  • Free white-glove delivery
  • 15-year warranty
  • Price: $599–$1,499

With Saatva, you don’t have to spend a fortune to sleep on a truly luxurious mattress. Featuring two layers of coils, the Saatva mattress will keep your spine in perfect alignment in all sleeping positions. What’s more, whether you’re looking for the best firm innerspring mattress or a softer model, Saatva has it all. Depending on your sleep preferences, you can choose one of three firmness levels—plush soft, luxury firm, or firm.

The base layer is constructed with tempered steel coils, which offer amazing support and durability. On top of it, there’s a layer of individually wrapped coils that reduce motion transfer while conforming to a sleeper’s body.

What’s more, the Saatva features a Euro pillow top, which offers amazing cushioning and contouring. Finally, the cover of this best rated innerspring pillow top mattress is made of organic cotton, which makes it very soft and breathable.

Besides selling a high-quality mattress, Saatva offers amazing buyer’s perks, such as free white-glove delivery and a 15-year warranty. Plus, you can try your new mattress for 120 nights before you decide if it’s the right fit for your needs. 

PROS:

  • Three firmness levels
  • Lumbar zone technology
  • Excellent edge support

CONS:

  • Heavy and difficult to move

8. WinkBeds Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - WinkBeds

Rating: 8.4

  • Type: Dual hybrid
  • 120-night trial
  • Free shipping
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Price: $1,049–$1,849

The WinkBed mattress is another example of a luxurious hybrid you can get at a reasonable price. Thanks to its amazing features, it’s one of the top rated innerspring mattresses. Since there’s a choice of four firmness levels, most sleepers will be satisfied with the feel this bed offers.

Thanks to individually wrapped coils, the WinkBed provides perfect spinal support. An additional layer of micro-coils contributes to body contouring and temperature regulation. Besides adding to the luxurious feel, the Euro pillow top with gel-infused foam offers some nice pressure relief. However, this might not be enough for some side sleepers since they may need a greater amount of cushioning. Thus, we can’t say it’s the best hybrid innerspring mattress for this sleep position.

This hybrid mattress by WinkBeds might be a solid pick for hot sleepers since it’s very breathable and doesn’t retain heat. It also features a Tencel cover that will help you sleep cool night after night.

You can also sleep peacefully knowing that your bed is covered by a lifetime warranty. Plus, in case the WinkBed doesn’t meet your expectations, you can get your money back since there’s a 120-night trial period. Considering these shopping perks, this must be one of the best innerspring mattress brands.

PROS:

  • Excellent temperature regulation
  • Four firmness levels
  • Great spinal support

CONS:

  • Not cushioning enough for some side sleepers

9. Tuft and Needle Hybrid Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Tuft and Needle

Rating: 8.3

  • Type: Hybrid
  • 100-night trial
  • Free shipping
  • 10-year warranty
  • Price: $895–$1,745

A well-established mattress brand, Tuft & Needle offers a very comfy hybrid mattress. It features a quite interesting and unique construction. Its support layer is made of individually wrapped tempered coils, which are pretty durable and provide amazing spinal support. In addition, there’s a layer of Nano coils, which adds more bounce to the mattress. Some of the best innerspring mattresses’ reviews claim that this layer greatly contributes to the mattress’s responsiveness.

The comfort layer is made of the proprietary Adaptive foam, which provides nice pressure relief but doesn’t sink as much as memory foam. A plush pillow-top offers additional contouring and cushioning.

Since the Hybrid by T&N is very responsive and bouncy, it’s a solid pick for combo sleepers. It’s also great for amorous activities. However, you should know that this mattress won’t dampen motion transfer completely, so it isn’t the best rated hybrid innerspring mattress for people sharing a bed with light sleepers.

Thanks to its hybrid construction, the mattress is very breathable. In addition, the Adaptive foam is infused with graphite and gel beads to further improve its cooling properties.

PROS:

  • Excellent temperature regulation
  • Responsive
  • Good edge support

CONS:

  • Average motion isolation

10. Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid Mattress Review

Best Innerspring Mattress - Brooklyn Bedding

Rating: 8.1

  • Type: Hybrid
  • 120-night trial
  • Free shipping
  • 10-year warranty
  • Price: $549–$1,049

The Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid mattress is a great pick for anyone looking for the best medium firm innerspring mattress. This affordable mattress offers great spinal support and nice pressure relief, so it will suit most sleepers.

Individually wrapped coils in the support layer will keep your spine in perfect alignment, while a layer of comfort foam will contour to your body, allowing for some pleasant pressure relief. The mattress is topped with quilted gel memory foam, which provides additional comfort.

Since the coils are individually wrapped, they minimize motion transfer quite well. In addition, the foam layers absorb vibrations, making this mattress the best inexpensive innerspring mattress for couples. 

The Brooklyn Bowery Hybrid also has great temperature regulation since the coil system promotes natural airflow. Plus, gel memory foam doesn’t retain body heat like memory foam does.

It’s great that you can try this mattress for 120 nights before you decide whether it’s a keeper. What’s more, it’s covered by a 10-year warranty.

PROS:

  • Good motion isolation
  • Great temperature regulation
  • Good spinal support

CONS:

  • Not enough cushioning for some side sleepers

How We Picked the Best Innerspring Mattress

Our Ranking Methodology

Considering the wide selection of mattresses on the market, finding the right innerspring mattress for your needs isn’t so simple. To make your decision-making process less time-consuming, we prepared this top 10 list. And now you can see the most important criteria our team of experts used to rank the mattresses.

Comfort Level

The level of comfort is a highly subjective matter since it greatly depends on a sleeper’s body weight and preferred sleeping position. While the best rated innerspring mattresses for a side sleeper would probably be a softer mattress with a high amount of sinkage, stomach sleepers typically need firmer mattresses that don’t sink too much.

However, regardless of your sleeping needs and preferences, a good innerspring mattress should keep your spine properly aligned. Therefore, we focussed on the amount of support a bed provides in different sleeping positions.

Quality

Getting the best mattress with an innerspring support core means that you’ll be able to sleep on a comfortable bed for many years to come. Keep in mind that a worn-out, sagging mattress doesn’t only look bad, but it can cause you aches and pains. So even though a mattress made of low-quality materials might be cheaper, spending a bit more will pay off in the long run.

Since coils make up the largest part of an innerspring mattress, we paid special attention to their type, gauge, and count for each of the top rated innerspring mattress brands we reviewed. However, we also carefully inspected other parts of a mattress’s construction, such as the materials used for the base layer, the foams in the comfort layer, and the mattress’s cover.

To find out as much as we can about the materials and longevity of the mattresses, we also went through hundreds of customers’ reviews.

Trial Period and Return Policy

Most well-known mattress-in-a-box brands offer a trial period if you decide to purchase their product. This allows you to use a mattress for a certain amount of time before you decide if it’s the best innerspring mattress you can get for the money.

We believe that this is the best way to find out if a mattress is the right fit for your needs. Therefore, we reviewed only the mattress brands that offer this amazing perk. Besides the length of the trial period, we also considered the return policy and how simple the entire process is.

Warranty

When shopping for a mattress, it’s vital to check if a manufacturer offers a warranty, what its duration is, and what the terms and conditions may be. Since getting a bed from one of the best rated innerspring mattress brands isn’t a small investment, we don’t recommend you buy an innerspring mattress without a warranty.

That’s why all mattresses on our top 10 list come with a warranty. In fact, most of them are covered for at least 10 years, and some even longer.

Price

We reviewed innerspring mattresses with different price tags in order to compare what they offer. Our goal was to present you with high-quality, comfy beds in different price ranges because regardless of your budget, you should get the best value for your money. If budget is your primary concern, you can also check out our list of the best cheap mattresses.

How to Choose the Best Innerspring Mattress

Buyer’s Guide

Invented in the 19th century, innerspring mattresses are the oldest type of bed on the mattress market. Even though today there are a number of new mattress types—made of polyfoam, memory foam, latex, and other materials—innerspring beds are still widely popular.

Before we delve into the details of the innerspring construction, and its pros and cons, we need to emphasize that innerspring mattresses refer to all bed types that have coils in the support layer.

Therefore, they’re usually classified as traditional innerspring or hybrid mattresses. So if you’re looking for the best coil mattress, you should know that the main difference between the two types is in their comfort layer. While traditional mattresses usually feature a thin layer of padding, hybrid mattresses have a few layers of foam or latex.

So here’s what you need to know when shopping for a new innerspring mattress:

Characteristics of Innerspring Mattresses

  • More Responsive: Innerspring mattresses tend to be bouncier than other types of mattresses. As a result, sleepers don’t sink into the mattress, but there’s also more motion transfer.
  • Less Contouring: Even the best coil mattresses generally provide less contouring than foam and latex mattresses. Since they don’t provide a high amount of pressure relief, they’re often not recommended for side sleepers.
  • Better Temperature Regulation: The spring system allows for natural airflow, so this type of mattress doesn’t retain much body heat. If you compare a foam vs. spring mattress, this is one of the crucial differences between the two mattress types.
  • Solid Edge Support: Most innersprings feature strong edge support thanks to their coil structure in the support layer. This is good to know if you’re looking for the best spring mattress for couples.

Types of Coils

Most innerspring mattresses use one of four types of coils:

Bonnell coils are easily recognized by their hourglass shape. They’re the oldest type of springs, most commonly found in inexpensive mattresses. However, despite this, they’re more than supportive enough. Since they’re made of tempered steel, Bonnell coils are quite durable. Individual coils of this type are all interconnected with a long spiral wire.

Offset coils can be found in some of the best spring mattresses. They look very similar to Bonnell coils since they’re also made of tempered steel and have an hourglass shape. However, their bottom is not rounded, but straightened. This update in their design improves the hinging effect and minimizes the gap between coils. 

Within this category, there are also double offset coils, which are straightened at both ends. Another type of offset springs is free arm offset coils, which are not interconnected. All types of offset coils provide a great amount of support, so they’re suitable even for the best innerspring mattress for obese people. In addition, since they’re more durable than Bonnell coils, they’re often more expensive as well.

Continuous coils are actually a row of coils made of a single wire. Even though mattresses with this type of coil system are quite supportive, they have a few drawbacks. First, they don’t perform well when it comes to motion transfer. Second, they may produce a lot of noise. And finally, these affordable mattresses typically don’t offer enough contouring.

Pocketed or pocket coils are individually encased in fiber. Therefore, they’re also known as encased coils. Here’s what you need to know when shopping for the best pocket coil mattress: This type of spring system doesn’t use any additional wires for interconnecting the coils. Instead, they’re often joined with hot glue. A pocket coil mattress is designed to minimize motion transfer and improve body contouring.

Coil Gauge

The coil gauge can tell you if a mattress is a good choice for your needs. It refers to the thickness of the coil wire, which affects the mattress’s firmness level. The coil gauge typically ranges from 12 to 18. However, thinner wires don’t have lower coil gauges—it’s quite the opposite. So if you need the best extra firm innerspring mattress, look for lower coil gauges (thicker wires), and vice versa.

Keep in mind that the coil gauge isn’t the sole factor that affects the mattress’s feel and quality. You should also pay attention to the coil count. Nevertheless, a mattress with a large number of thinner coils can be of the same quality as a mattress with fewer coils but made of thicker wire.

Coil Count

As we already mentioned, the number of coils or coil count can affect the quality of a mattress. A high coil count usually means a greater level of contouring and a longer lifespan. Most of the best spring mattress brands produce beds with 500 to 1,000 coils. While mattresses with fewer than 300 coils are often of poor quality, mattresses with more than 1,000 coils don’t necessarily perform better.

Advantages of Innerspring Mattresses

  • Most innerspring mattresses are bouncier than other types of beds, which makes them a good option for sex.
  • Innersprings tend to sleep cooler than foam and latex mattresses thanks to better air circulation.
  • Customers rarely complain about off-gassing. This is another noticeable difference between an innerspring mattress vs. foam models.
  • There’s a wide choice of innerspring models.

Disadvantages of Innerspring Mattresses

  • Innerspring mattresses provide less pressure relief than foam and latex mattresses.
  • Some innersprings are noisy.
  • Innerspring models usually don’t isolate motion as well as foam mattresses.

FAQs

What is the best innerspring mattress to purchase?

Your choice should primarily depend on your sleep needs and preferences. Some of the best mattress brands selling innerspring models include Naturepedic, Leesa, DreamFoam, Saatva, and Tuft & Needle. You can also check out our top 10 list of innerspring mattresses above.

Which is better, a memory foam or innerspring mattress?

Both memory foam and innerspring mattresses have their pros and cons. The choice between the two types will depend on your sleep preferences. For example, side sleepers usually need a high level of pressure relief, so memory foam beds might be better for them. On the other hand, innerspring mattresses don’t sink too much, which makes them a solid pick for stomach sleepers.

What is the best innerspring mattress for side sleepers?

Since side sleepers typically need lots of cushioning and contouring, hybrid innerspring models are better for them than traditional innerspring mattresses. They commonly feature several foam or latex layers in their comfort layer, so they provide more relief for sensitive pressure points.

What is an innerspring mattress?

An innerspring mattress is a type of bed that features an innerspring system in the support layer. There are different types of coils that are used in innerspring models. You can read more about them above. Plus, they’re often classified into traditional and hybrid innerspring mattresses, depending on the composition of their comfort layers.

Do innerspring mattresses need a boxspring?

No, typically they don’t need a boxspring to provide you with an adequate level of comfort. However, it’s recommended to check the terms and conditions of your mattress’s warranty since sometimes a warranty might become void if you don’t place your mattress on a specific type of bed frame.

Do innerspring mattresses squeak?

Some innerspring models might be noisy, but not all models produce the same amount of sound. Innerspring mattresses that use pocket coils are virtually silent because the coils are individually wrapped in fiber, which minimizes noise.

Is an innerspring mattress good for back pain?

Innerspring mattresses can be good for back pain if they provide ample spinal support. This way, they’ll keep your spine in proper alignment. Plus, they should also offer some pressure relief, especially for shoulders and hips.

How long does an innerspring mattress last?

Most innerspring models are expected to last 7–10 years. Their lifespan mostly depends on the quality of materials used as well as the type of coils.

Wrapping Up

Since innerspring models are so common on the mattress market, you can easily get overwhelmed with the number of options. That’s why we compiled our top 10 list and prepared a comprehensive guide with all the things you should consider when shopping for a new coil mattress.

Hopefully, all this together will help you find the best innerspring mattress for your needs.

Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More