The 10 Best Mattress Toppers in 2021 (Reviewed & Compared)

An Additional Layer of Pure Comfort on Your Bed!

July 9, 2021

If you’re looking for a way to make your current mattress more comfortable, then you’ve come to the right place. Mattress toppers can make your mattress feel firmer or plusher, depending on your needs. They are usually around one inch to three inches thick and are made from a variety of materials, including memory foam, latex, and down. 

Today, we’ve chosen the top 10 mattress topper options, and reviewed and compared them so you can decide which is the best mattress topper for you. 

We’ve rated these according to:

  • Comfort 
  • Firmness
  • Support
  • Craftsmanship
  • Value for money
  • Durability

Our Top Three Picks

10 Best Mattress Toppers to Buy in 2021

We aim to review the best sleep-related products on the market. If you make a purchase through one of the links on our site, we may earn a commission. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure.

Company
Features
Overall Score
Best Mattress Topper - PlushBeds Review
Editor’s Choice
  • Check icon

    100% natural Talalay latex

  • Check icon

    OEKO-TEX Standard 100 & GreenGuard Gold Certified

  • Check icon

    Choice of thickness and firmness

Best Mattress Topper - Puffy Review
Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper
  • Check icon

    Hypoallergenic

  • Check icon

    Breathable bamboo fabric

  • Check icon

    Deep stretch pockets

Best Mattress Topper - Parachute Review
Best Luxury Mattress Topper
  • Check icon

    Evenly distributed fill for proper support

  • Check icon

    Down and feather combination for a fluffy feel

  • Check icon

    Soft 100% sateen cotton shell

Best Mattress Topper - Amerisleep Review
Best Mattress Topper for Back Pain
  • Check icon

    Targeted support for sensitive areas

  • Check icon

    Open-cell foam for increased breathability

  • Check icon

    Micro grip base prevents slipping

Best Mattress Topper - Brooklyn Bedding Review
Best Affordable Mattress Topper
  • Check icon

    2” or 3” options

  • Check icon

    CertiPUR-US certified

  • Check icon

    Cooling gel

Best Mattress Topper - Eco Terra Review
Best Latex Mattress Topper
  • Check icon

    OEKO-TEX Standard 100 & Eco-Institut certified

  • Check icon

    Three firmness options

  • Check icon

    100% natural Talalay latex

Best Mattress Topper - Layla Review
Best Mattress Topper for Side Sleepers
  • Check icon

    Antimicrobial copper infusion

  • Check icon

    Advanced cooling technology

  • Check icon

    Distributes weight evenly

Best Mattress Topper - Nest Bedding Review
Best Cooling Mattress Topper
  • Check icon

    Cooling cover

  • Check icon

    Exceptional comfort

  • Check icon

    Corner straps hold it in place

Best Mattress Topper - Saatva Review
Best Pain Relieving Mattress Toppers
  • Check icon

    Graphite, latex, or memory foam

  • Check icon

    Great for pain relief

  • Check icon

    Different firmness levels according to material

Best Mattress Topper - Tempur-Pedic Review
Best Hypoallergenic Mattress Topper
  • Check icon

    Supportive TEMPUR material

  • Check icon

    Resistant to dust and mold

  • Check icon

    Durable and long-lasting

Top 10 Mattress Toppers Reviews

Perhaps you’ve bought the best cheap mattress and are looking to add some more luxury to it, or maybe you want to firm up your soft memory foam mattress. A mattress topper is a great way to do that. Here, we’ve reviewed and compared the best options on the market so you can choose the best one for you.

PlushBeds Natural Latex Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - PlushBeds Mattress Topper Review
  • Editor's Choice

  • Type: Latex

  • Warranty: Five-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $288.00–$787.00

PROS :
  • Great bounce due to the 100% natural Talalay latex

  • No harmful chemicals and organically certified

  • You can decide how thick and firm you want it

CONS :
  • Some motion transfer due to bounce

The PlushBeds Natural Latex Topper is made from 100% natural Talalay latex, and we consider it to be the best mattress topper in 2021. One of the things we like best about this mattress topper is the variety of choices there are. For example, you can decide the thickness and firmness level you want. It’s available in two or three inches and soft, medium-soft, medium, medium-firm, or extra-firm. 

If you choose one of the softer mattress topper options, you’ll find your body nicely cradled and your pressure points accommodated. The firmer options give amazing spinal support, which makes the extra-firm perfect for people with back pain. The natural Talalay latex has a nice bounce to it and makes getting in and out of bed a lot easier. 

This best latex mattress topper is also super durable thanks to the quality of the latex and the 100% organic cotton cover that you can easily remove to clean. You can expect this topper to last up to 20 years without any sagging or support issues. 

Puffy Mattress Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - Puffy Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Memory Foam Mattress Topper

  • Type: Memory foam

  • Trial: 101-night sleep trial

  • Warranty: Lifetime warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $179.00–$249.00

Rating 9.7

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • Hypoallergenic fabric

  • Super breathable so you won’t overheat

  • Can attach to any mattress up to 15”

CONS :
  • Not made locally

This product from Puffy is our pick for the best memory foam mattress topper available today. It’s made from premium CertiPUR-US certified memory foam that is both supportive and comfortable. It comes in a firm or a soft option and is two inches thick.

If you’re looking to firm up your mattress or add an extra layer of support for your pressure points, this is a great option. Even the soft topper will make sure that your body is fully supported while you rest. However, if you want to add a layer of plushness, you may want to consider the Puffy Mattress Pad, which is less solid and allows you to sink into it a little bit more. 

This top-rated memory foam mattress topper comes with a breathable bamboo cover that is hypoallergenic. It’s cool to the touch, so you don’t have to worry about overheating during the night. It also has super-stretch pockets so it can attach to any mattress up to 15 inches. Of course, you can use this topper on any mattress; it doesn’t have to be a Puffy Lux mattress or one of their other models.

Parachute Down Mattress Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - Parachute Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Luxury Mattress Topper

  • Type: Down

  • Trial: 60-day trial

  • Warranty: Three-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $269.00–$399.00

Rating 9.8

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • Super plush and luxurious feel

  • Filling is evenly distributed for comfort

  • Conforms to body shape

CONS :
  • Can sleep hot

The Parachute Down Mattress Topper is one of the best-rated mattress toppers available for purchase in 2021. If you want to feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud while still enjoying great pressure point relief, this luxurious mattress topper is perfect for you. With a gusset height of three inches and quality European white down, you’ll feel like you’re sleeping in a five-star hotel suite. 

This super soft and plush topper is filled with a mixture of 85% down and 15% down and feather fibers. It offers a decent amount of support, but it’s not ideal for people with back or neck pain. It’s better suited for people who need to sleep on a softer surface. 

If you sleep on your side or your back, you may find this best-rated mattress topper to be a super comfortable option. However, it’s not great for stomach sleepers as they need something a little firmer. 

While this is a super luxurious mattress topper, it’s important to note that the down filling can retain heat, so it’s not for people who sleep hot or suffer from night sweats. 

Lift by Amerisleep Mattress Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - Lift by Amerisleep Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Mattress Topper for Back Pain

  • Type: Memory foam

  • Warranty: Five-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $199.00–$349.00

Rating 9.9

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • HIVE technology offers superior support and comfort

  • Won’t slip off mattress due to grip at the base

  • Open-cell structure gives great airflow

CONS :
  • Off-gassing smell at first

This is our choice for the best-rated mattress topper for back pain that you can currently buy in the United States. Just like the Amerisleep mattress on our best mattresses list, this topper offers pure comfort and support. The HIVE technology actively supports your whole body and relieves pressure points, which is great for anyone struggling with back or neck pain. This is a better choice than the Parachute Down Mattress Topper for anyone who needs extra pressure relief or spinal support. 

The open-cell structure of the memory foam also creates excellent airflow in this mattress topper, so it will prevent you from overheating while you sleep. The grip at the bottom of the mattress topper also ensures that it won’t slip or move when it’s attached to the top of your mattress.

This is the best mattress topper for lower back pain, and it’s also super durable and comfortable, giving you superior support while you sleep. The only downsides to purchasing this mattress topper are that you will have to wait for it to expand, and it has a slight off-gassing smell at first.

Brooklyn Bedding 2.5-lb. Gel Swirl Memory Foam Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Affordable Mattress Topper

  • Type: Memory foam

  • Warranty: Three-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $50.00–$110.00

Rating 9.5

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • You can choose your thickness

  • No harmful chemicals

  • Prevents overheating

CONS :
  • Not necessarily long-lasting

If you don’t want to spend a large amount of cash but still want to transform your current mattress, we suggest this best-rated, affordable gel memory foam mattress topper. It’s a less expensive option that still has plenty of benefits. The 2.5-lb gel swirl memory foam offers pretty decent spinal support and has a plush firmness that is super comfortable. 

We’ve found that it’s quite good at preventing overheating while sleeping, thanks to the cooling gel in the memory foam slab. Our experiments found that it doesn’t retain heat, so it can be helpful for people who suffer from night sweats. 

Unfortunately, we don’t think it will necessarily last as long as some other products on our best mattress toppers list. While it does have a three-year warranty, it might start to deteriorate soon after its warranty expires. However, that depends a lot on the way you treat it. 

Eco Terra 100% Natural Latex Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - Eco Terra Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Latex Mattress Topper

  • Type: Latex

  • Warranty: Five-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $173.00–$527.00

Rating 9.6

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • No harmful chemicals

  • Choice of firmness levels and thickness

  • Durable and long-lasting

CONS :
  • Can get expensive, depending on size, thickness, and firmness level

You can easily sleep in any position with this top-rated mattress topper made out of natural Talalay latex. We honestly think it’s super comfortable, whether you sleep on your back or side. However, you may want to choose a firmer option if you’re planning on sleeping on your stomach. 

We found that this Eco Terra mattress topper offers superior pressure relief. It’s highly unlikely that you’ll wake up with any aches and pains because this latex topper cradles your body and relieves all of your pressure points individually. You can also choose the firmness level you prefer, from soft, medium, and medium-firm options. You can also decide whether you want it to be two or three inches thick. 

Latex mattress topper reviews tend to agree that this mattress topper has a nice bounce to it. It isolates motion well enough that it won’t wake a partner, but it’s bouncy enough to make it easy to switch positions and get out of bed. 

Layla Memory Foam Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - Layla Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Mattress Topper for Side Sleepers

  • Type: Memory foam

  • Trial: 120-night trial

  • Warranty: Five-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $249.00–$449.00

Rating 9.8

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • Super hygienic

  • Cooling

  • Soft yet fully supportive

CONS :
  • Some might find it too soft, especially if on a soft mattress

This best memory foam topper is in the same quality range as Layla mattresses. In fact, it has the same plush supportiveness as the soft side of Layla’s flippable mattress. It somehow manages to be soft and cushy while still relieving pressure points and offering great spinal support. 

We found it extremely comfortable, especially for sleeping on your side. It lets your hips and shoulders sink in just enough, and you’ll still feel fully supported throughout the night. We definitely suggest this option for people who sleep on their side the majority of the time. It might be a bit soft for people who sleep on their stomachs. 

Memory foam mattress topper reviews agree with us that this mattress is wonderfully cooling thanks to the copper gel beads, which also keep the mattress sanitary and clean. The copper gel beads draw the heat away from your body while you sleep, letting you sleep nice and cool.

Nest Bedding Cooling Topper Review

Best Mattress Topper - Nest Bedding Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Cooling Mattress Topper

  • Type: Energex foam

  • Trial: 100-night trial

  • Warranty: Two-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $199.00–$299.00

Rating 9.9

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • Cooling cover

  • Suits all sleeping positions

  • Corner straps stop movement

CONS :
  • Some may prefer the hug of memory foam

This top-rated cooling mattress topper is like a micro version of the Alexander Signature mattress from Nest Bedding. So if you want to transform your mattress into a comfortable cooling bed, but you don’t have the money to buy a whole new mattress, this is a great option. 

The Energex foam and phase-change cover in this topper draws heat away from your body as you sleep. This means you don’t end up lying in your excess body heat all night. These two components working together make this a wonderful cooling mattress topper. 

We’ve found that this highest-rated mattress topper helps to soothe aches and pains in your body. So if you are an active person, you should definitely test out this topper if you can’t buy a new mattress. 

The only problem with the Energex foam is that it doesn’t give you the same full-body hug you may expect from a memory foam mattress. 

Saatva Mattress Toppers Review

Best Mattress Topper - Saatva Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Pain Relieving Mattress Toppers

  • Type: Graphite, latex, or memory foam

  • Trial: 45-day trial

  • Warranty: One-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $160.00–$540.00

Rating 9.7

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • Choice of material

  • Great pain relief

  • Three firmness levels

CONS :
  • Cover isn’t machine-washable

These three different top-rated mattress toppers from Saatva are all great choices, depending on your needs. You have the choice of graphite, latex, or high-density memory foam. You’ll find that the latex is the most expensive, while the high-density memory foam is quite a bit cheaper, but they are all worth the price. 

The three options have different firmness levels. The graphite topper is the softest option. We found it to be around 5.5 out of 10. The high-density memory foam is the firmest option, at around 7 out of 10. The latex option is in the middle of the three and offers a comfortable medium-firm feel. 

In our mattress topper review, we want to highlight that the latex and graphite are naturally cooling and work well to draw heat away from your body. On the other hand, if you tend to sleep hot, the high-density memory foam isn’t a good choice because we discovered that it tends to retain heat.

TEMPUR-Topper Supreme Review

Best Mattress Topper - Tempur-Pedic Mattress Topper Review
  • Best Hypoallergenic Mattress Topper

  • Type: TEMPUR material

  • Trial: No trial

  • Warranty: 10-year warranty

  • Free shipping: Yes

  • Price: $299.00–$449.00

Rating 9.8

Get the Best Deal
PROS :
  • Contours to your body

  • Resistant to dust and mold

  • Durable and long-lasting

CONS :
  • Can retain heat if you sleep very hot

This is one of the best foam mattress topper options, created using the proprietary TEMPUR material that makes this brand so incredibly popular. This material has a dense memory foam feel that contours completely to your body while you’re sleeping but doesn’t retain your shape once you get up. 

We found that despite the denseness of the mattress topper, it had a medium-firm feel, around 5.5 out of 10. The thing we loved the most is how it adapts to your body, even when you change positions. This offers superior relief to the pressure points throughout your body. 

After some testing, we discovered that this is the best mattress topper if you have an innerspring mattress that you don’t find quite comfortable enough. It adds a layer of foam between you and the springs, giving your body a great deal of comfort while still retaining the benefits of a spring mattress. 

How to Find the Best Mattress Topper in 2021

– Buyer’s Guide –

There are so many options when it comes to mattress toppers that it can feel almost impossible to choose the right one. That’s why you need to know a few things when shopping for a mattress topper. 

Mattress Toppers vs. Mattress Pads

Mattress pads are a lot thinner than mattress toppers. The mattress pad simply changes the firmness level of the mattress. On the other hand, mattress toppers change the whole feel of the mattress by adding plushness, firmness, cooling technology, or luxury to the bed. 

Type

According to mattress topper reviews, there are different types of mattress toppers, and they can use different materials, including: 

Down

Goose- or duck-down mattress toppers are luxurious and plush, adding a wonderfully soft feel to your mattress. 

Down-alternative

Down-alternative mattress toppers offer an allergy-friendly and often vegan alternative to down while still providing the same plush comfort. 

Memory foam

Memory foam contours to your body, gives you an extra feeling of support, and can relieve your pressure points. Often something is added to the memory foam to make it more breathable or cooling. 

Latex 

You’ll notice in any latex mattress topper review that these generally have a bit of a bounce to them. They can be super supportive, depending on the brand. 

Thickness

Mattress toppers come in many different thickness options. Some brands even offer the same product with different thickness options. You’ll find that thickness varies from 2” to 4.5” in most cases. 

Firmness

The firmness levels of mattress toppers vary according to brand and product. You’ll find that many of them, especially those on the list above, offer a range of firmness options. The firmness level should be mentioned in any mattress topper review

Warranty

When buying a mattress topper, you should check the warranty. This will give you an idea of the durability of the mattress topper. You should note, however, that mattress toppers generally last longer than their warranty period.

Wrapping Up 

At the end of the day, the mattress topper that you choose to purchase depends on your needs. However, the above list is a great place to start. Our mini-reviews are highly informative and will help you make a well-informed decision.

FAQs

What is the best mattress topper?

In our opinion, the PlushBeds mattress topper is the best option available in 2021. It offers wonderful support and comfort. The latex used is also 100% natural Talalay latex that is OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified. Of course, we believe that you’ll be happy with any one of the 10 mattress topper options we reviewed above. 

Do mattress toppers really work?

Yes, as long as you purchase a quality mattress topper, it can completely change the feel of your bed. If you don’t have the cash to purchase a new mattress or simply want to add a little extra comfort to your existing mattress, these are great options.

What thickness of a mattress topper should I get?

That depends on what you want from your mattress topper. A thinner option is okay if you’re looking to simply add a small change to the feel of your current mattress, like adding cooling effects. However, if you want to change the level of firmness of your mattress or add a plusher feel, you should consider a thicker option. 

Which is better: a memory foam or a gel mattress topper?

It depends on the type of comfort you’re looking for. Memory foam and gel mattress toppers have different benefits. Gel foam mattresses are generally cooler, while memory foam contours to the body nicely. It’s best to look at the individual products as they’ll have different features that will help you choose. 

What is the best mattress topper for lower back and hip pain?

The Amerisleep Mattress Topper is the best mattress topper for people with lower back and hip pain. It has HIVE technology, which helps give excellent spinal support and relieves pressure on the body.