The Best Pillow Top Mattresses in 2020 (Reviewed & Compared)

Get a Cloudlike Mattress for a Restful Sleep

October 8, 2020

Pillow top mattresses provide the best of the two worlds—the bouncing feel of the traditional innerspring mattress and the soft feel that can easily be described as sleeping on a fluffy cloud. 

However, if you find it hard to find the best pillow top mattress that will fit your nocturnal needs, look no further. We tested several mattresses to find the best one, basing our decision on the following criteria: 

  • Comfort
  • Quality
  • Buying Perks
  • Value for Money
  • Customer Reviews

 So let’s get down to business.

Best Pillow Top Mattresses

  • Best pillow top mattress in 2020 - Saatva
  • Best pillow top mattress for side sleepers - Awara
  • Best cheap pillow top mattress - Amore Beds

The Top 10 Best Pillow Top Mattresses

Company
Features
Overall Score
1.
Saatva Review
Best Pillow Top Mattress in 2020
  • Check icon

    Long durability

  • Check icon

    Eco-friendly materials

  • Check icon

    Great mattress for combination sleepers

2.
Awara Review
Best Pillow Top Mattress for Side Sleepers
  • Check icon

    Cover made of organic cotton

  • Check icon

    For overweight side sleepers

  • Check icon

    Great cooling system

3.
Amore Beds Review
Best Cheap Pillow Top Mattress
  • Check icon

    For heavyweight back and stomach sleepers

  • Check icon

    Made of natural materials

  • Check icon

    Low price

4.
Helix Review
Best Mattress for Couples
  • Check icon

    Fast body adjustment

  • Check icon

    Excellent motion isolation and edge support

  • Check icon

    For side sleepers that suffer from back pain

5.
Avocado Review
Best Euro Top Mattress That’s Eco-Friendly
  • Check icon

    For back sleepers over 130 pounds

  • Check icon

    One of the best cooling systems

  • Check icon

    Made of natural, organic materials

6.
Winkbeds Review
Best Pillow Top Hybrid Mattress
  • Check icon

    Exceptional edge support

  • Check icon

    Four levels of firmness

  • Check icon

    For combination sleepers

7.
Brentwood Review
Best Pillow Top Mattress for Stomach Sleepers
  • Check icon

    For stomach and back sleepers

  • Check icon

    Good cooling system

  • Check icon

    Eco-friendly materials

8.
Dreamcloud Review
Best Plush Pillow Top Mattress
  • Check icon

    For side and back sleepers

  • Check icon

    1-year free trial

  • Check icon

    Fluffy top with a strong coil foundation

9.
Nest Bedding Review
Most Cooling Pillow Top Mattress
  • Check icon

    Eco-friendly materials

  • Check icon

    Designed for all types of sleepers

  • Check icon

    Three firmness levels

10.
Naturepedic Review
Most Customizable Pillow Top Mattress
  • Check icon

    GOTS certified organic materials

  • Check icon

    Five firmness levels

  • Check icon

    Ideal for couples with different sleep preferences

Best Pillow Top Mattress Reviews 

1. Saatva Classic Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Saatva Classic Mattress Review
  • Type: Innerspring

  • 180-night trial

  • 15-year warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Eight standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $799–$1,799

Rating 9.8

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Long durability (7–10 years)

  • Eco-friendly materials

  • Great mattress for combination sleepers

  • Three firmness levels

  • Suitable for people with back pain

CONS:
  • Not the best motion isolation

  • Slow delivery time

Many best pillow top mattress reviews mention Saatva, which comes as no surprise since this mattress is unique. It’s made of several materials, including memory foam, polyfoam, and pocketed coils. The top is made of polyfoam and fiber that provides a gentle cooling effect, while the foundation relies on innerspring. Moreover, you can pick a Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, or Firm mattress. 

What’s the difference? Sleepers under 130 pounds with back problems should choose the Plush Soft model, since this is the best pillow top mattress for back pain, while more massive individuals (over 230 pounds) should pick the Firm model. 

The Saatva Classic mattress comes with a 180-night trial and a 15-year warranty.

2. Awara Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Awara Review
  • Type: Hybrid

  • 365-night trial

  • Lifetime warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Six standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $899–$1,399

Rating 9.7

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Cover made of organic cotton

  • Best Natural Organic Mattress award

  • Great cooling system

CONS:
  • Lightweight individuals might find the mattress too firm

There are many great organic hybrid mattresses, and Awara Organic Luxury Hybrid Mattress is the best medium firm pillow top mattress for overweight side sleepers and lightweight back and stomach sleepers. The cover is made of organic cotton, and it’s supported by Dunlop Latex. The pocketed coils that create a bouncing effect serve as the foundation and prevent you from sinking too deep.

The motion isolation is good, and the latex provides a cool effect, so hot sleepers won’t have overheating problems. Besides having the best medium-firm mattress with pillow top, Awara is a proud owner of the Best Natural Organic Mattress award. In the like manner, they are a TuV-certified ClimatePartner, so for every sold mattress, Awara plants a tree. 

Awara Organic Luxury Hybrid mattress comes with a 365-night trial and a lifetime warranty.

3. Amore Natural Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Amore Beds Natural Mattress Review
  • Type: Hybrid mattress

  • 100-night trial

  • 25-year warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Six standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $775–$1500

Rating 9.5

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Best pillow top mattress cover made of natural materials

  • Great for heavyweight back and stomach sleepers

  • Low price

CONS:
  • Might be too firm for side sleepers

You can find a lot of cheap mattresses on the market, but what Amore offers is a cheap pillow top mattress that comes in four models: Luxury Hybrid Mattress, Hybrid Foam/Coil Mattress, Natural Hybrid Mattress, and 2-Sided Flippable Mattress. We’ll focus on the Natural Hybrid Mattress.

It’s made out of natural latex, organic cotton, and New Zealand wool, so if you’re a fan of natural materials, this eco-friendly mattress will be a perfect choice. Furthermore, the mattress is ideal for heavyweight individuals that tend to sleep on their back or stomach.

The Natural Hybrid mattress comes with a 100-night trial and a 25-year warranty.

4. Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress Review
  • Type: Hybrid

  • 100-night trial

  • 15-year warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Six standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $895–$1,999

Rating 9.3

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • The mattress adjusts fast to your body

  • It reduces pressure points on shoulders, knees, and hips

  • Great motion isolation and edge support

  • For side sleepers that suffer from back pain, as well as combination sleepers

CONS:
  • You can't remove the cover

Helix Midnight Luxe mattress is made of five layers. The foundation is made of DuraDense foam, followed by a thick layer of wrapped coils, polyfoam, and Gel Visco foam. The pillow top mattress cover is made of Tencel that provides a gentle cooling effect. 

It’s great for side sleepers that suffer from back pain, as well as combination sleepers. This medium-firm mattress has excellent motion isolation and admirable edge support, making it ideal for couples who tend to move a lot. 

The Helix Midnight Luxe mattress comes with a 100-night trial and a 15-year warranty.

5. Avocado Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Avocado Mattress Review
  • Type: Hybrid

  • 1-year trial

  • 25-year warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Six standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $899–$1,799

Rating 9.2

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Eco-friendly materials

  • Good for back sleepers over 130 pounds

  • One of the best cooling systems

  • Good edge support

CONS:
  • Side sleepers under 130 pounds might find the mattress too firm

Avocado is known to have a firm pillow top mattress that’s ideal for back sleepers. You can choose from three models: Green mattress, Vegan mattress, and Latex mattress. All mattresses are made of eco-friendly materials that include latex, coils, and organic cotton or wool cover. 

We’ll focus on the Green mattress model. It’s made of natural materials, including organic latex, wool, and cotton, that are supported by pocketed coils. Additionally, you can add two inches or more to your full-size pillow top mattress for a plushier feel. 

Furthermore, it has one of the best cooling systems. The latex reduces body heat, so you won’t have problems falling asleep. 

The Avocado Green mattress comes with a one-year trial and a 25-year warranty.

6. The WinkBed Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Winkbed Review
  • Type: Hybrid

  • 120-night trial

  • Lifetime warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Six standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $1,049–$1,849

Rating 9.0

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Exceptional edge support

  • Four levels of firmness

  • Great support system

  • Ideal for combination sleepers

CONS:
  • Some people might find the mattresses too firm

WinkBeds offers the best king size pillow top mattress for couples, and you can choose from three models: MemoryLux, EcoCloud, and WinkBed. The first model is made of foam, the second one is made of latex, and the third one is a hybrid. We’ll focus on the WinkBed model. 

You can choose the firmness level, starting from Softer, Luxury Firm, Firmer, and Plus. How are they different? If you want to get a plush pillow top mattress, pick the Softer model (firmness scale). The Luxury Firm model is medium-firm (firmness scale 6), while the Firmer and Plus models will offer you the firmest foundation (firmness scale 7–8).

WinkBed has one of the best edge support systems, thanks to its additional coil support. The mattresses are great for combination sleepers, as well as hot sleepers. 

The WinkBed mattress comes with a 120-night trial and a lifetime warranty.

7. Brentwood Oceano Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Brentwood Oceano Mattress Review
  • Type: Hybrid

  • 1-year trial

  • 25-year warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Seven standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $999–$2,398

Rating 8.9

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Ideal for stomach and back sleepers

  • Good cooling system

  • Made of eco-friendly materials

  • Has a GreenGuard Gold certification

CONS:
  • Heavy to move

  • Side sleepers might find it too firm

Oceano Luxury Hybrid Mattress has sound motion isolation, so you won’t be disturbed by your partner’s movements in the middle of the night. You should buy it if you want to have a luxurious, breathable, and thick pillow top for a mattress that’s made of eco-friendly materials.

This medium-firm mattress is an excellent choice for oversized stomach and back sleepers and couples. It’s made of memory foam and coils that provide additional support, while the cover takes care of heath accumulation. 

Oceano Luxury Hybrid mattress comes with a one-year trial and a 25-year warranty.

8. Dreamcloud Premier Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Dreamcloud Premier Mattress Review
  • Type: Hybrid

  • 365-night trial

  • Lifetime warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Six standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $699–$1,399

Rating 8.8

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • A great choice for side and back sleepers

  • Six layers provide the perfect balance

  • Ideal for hot sleepers

CONS:
  • Not the best choice for stomach sleepers

Dreamcloud Premier is known to have the best soft pillow top mattress made of a slushy top and strong coil foundation. This hybrid mattress has six layers, starting with a firm foam base, followed by a layer of close-fitting coils, transfer, memory foam, and cashmere cover. 

The mattress has proper edge support and is ideal for side and back sleepers and couples who love to sleep on a thick king size pillow top mattress.

The Dreamcloud Premier mattress comes with a 365-night trial and a lifetime warranty.

9. Nest Bedding Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Mattress Review
  • Type: Hybrid

  • 100-night trial

  • Lifetime warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Eight standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $949–$1,099

Rating 8.7

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Tailored for couples

  • Eco-friendly materials

  • Designed for all kind of sleepers

  • Three firmness levels

  • Excellent pressure relief

CONS:
  • You can't remove the cover

  • The mattress is pretty heavy

Nest currently offers several different mattresses like Alexander Signature Hybrid, Flippable, and Love & Sleep. Of these pillow top mattresses, we’ll review the Alexander Signature Hybrid model.

This model is mostly made of foam and coils spread out through five layers. You can choose the firmness level (Plush, Medium, Luxury Firm) of your liking. However, if you’re a combination sleeper, we’d recommend the medium-firm option.

It’s a perfect choice for couples since you can get one mattress with two different feels (one side can be firm, and one can be soft). However, according to the best king size pillow top mattress reviews, this option only comes with King and Cal King size.

Alexander Signature Hybrid mattress comes with a 100-night trial and a lifetime warranty.

10. Naturepedic EOS Pillowtop Mattress Review

Best Pillow Top Mattress - Naturepedic EOS Pillowtop Mattress Review
  • Type: Latex hybrid

  • 90-night trial

  • 20-year warranty

  • Free shipping

  • Six standard mattress sizes

  • Price: $2,499–$4,799

Rating 8.5

Get the Best Deal
PROS:
  • Organic materials

  • GOTS certified

  • Five firmness levels

  • Ideal for couples

  • Comfy and supportive

CONS:
  • Expensive

This Naturepedic mattress is often the best rated pillow top mattress for couples since it allows you to customize the firmness level of each side. You can choose from five different firmness levels, and if you’re not satisfied, you can swap any layer of the mattress for free within 90 days of your purchase.

While the pillow top and the comfort layers are constructed with organic cotton, wool, and latex, the support layer consists of individually wrapped coils. Therefore, this mattress offers excellent spinal support and pleasant body contouring without too much sinkage. Plus, since the mattress is made of organic materials, it doesn’t contain any toxic chemicals. 

Picking the Best Pillow Top Mattresses in 2020

– Our Ranking Methodology –

If you wonder how we made our list of the finest pillow top mattresses available, let’s walk you through our criteria.

Comfort and Quality

Comfort will significantly depend on the mattress’s type and responsiveness, while its quality will depend on its materials. We picked companies that use natural and eco-friendly materials like natural latex, organic cotton, wool, etc. 

Not only do these certified materials expand the durability of a mattress, but they also provide many health benefits (spinal alignment, pressure release, allergy reduction, etc.).

Best pillow top mattress covers are made of special gels that absorb heat. The main focus is to prevent the sleeper from overheating by providing a gentle and cool effect. Some mattress covers on our list can be removed and washed, while others can’t. 

Buying Perks

You shouldn’t judge the product basing your criteria solely on the quality of the materials or the comfort the mattresses provide. We also focused our attention on buying perks like a free trial, free shipping, and warranty duration in this pillow top mattress review. 

All companies on our list offer free trials (from 100 nights to 1 year), free shipping, and a warranty that provides free repairs and mattress replacements. 

Value for Money

Most pillow top mattresses on our list come with affordable prices, ranging from $370 to $2,398. The price difference will depend on the materials used. 

For example, a mattress with a Euro top will cost more than a mattress with a regular top, and a queen size pillow top mattress will cost more than a twin-sized mattress. That said, each company on our list offers fair prices for their products. 

Customer Reviews

We read (and watched) all the available customer reviews before making our final choice to get a deep insight into the product’s features, benefits, pros, cons, and values. This list is made according to our findings. 

How to Choose the Best Pillow Top Mattress

– Buyer’s Guide –

So you finally decided to buy a new mattress, but you’re not sure where to begin since there are so many options. The more you get to choose, the more confused you get. Should you buy a firm or soft mattress, should it be a flippable hybrid? 

Before you start panicking, here’s everything you need to know before buying.

What Is a Pillow Top Mattress?

Many pillow top mattress reviews explain that a pillow top mattress has an additional top layer that provides more comfort and better pressure relief, backed up with a strong innerspring foundation. It’s usually made of cotton or wool, but not as a strict rule. The top can be filled with latex or memory foam.

Pillow Top vs. Euro Top

There are two variations of this top—Regular and Euro. What’s the difference? The first one implies sewing the additional layer on top, while the second one implies sewing the additional layer under the cover that results in stronger edge support and a thicker look. 

Our pick for the best Euro top mattress is Saatva. 

Firmness Level

The mattresses usually come in three firmness options—soft, medium-firm, and firm. So how should you choose the right firmness? First, you need to ask yourself what are your main concerns and preferences. 

Do you need a mattress that will help you with back pain, or do you want one that will match your sleeping position? Maybe you want to find a double pillow top mattress with strong edge support that you can share with your partner?

When you answer these questions, you need to focus on your weight and sleeping position. These factors are essential when choosing the right firmness level. In other words, lightweight side and combination sleepers should always choose a soft or medium-soft mattress, while heavy back or combination sleepers should use a medium-firm mattress. 

Moreover, the best pillow top mattresses for stomach sleepers need to be firm.

Mattress Type

After you’ve chosen the firmness level you want, you need to choose a mattress type. 

There are a couple of types you can choose from: strong innerspring mattresses (for overweight individuals), soft memory foam mattresses (for lightweight side sleepers that like sinking in), high-quality latex mattresses (for people that like natural materials), or hybrid mattresses (for combination sleepers that like customizable or two-sided mattresses).

Pressure Relief

To reduce pressure from your hips and shoulders, you need to consider the mattress filling. For example, a twin pillow top mattress can be made of layers filled with air, fiber, foam, and gel. The best option is soft memory foam that’s adjustable to your body and sleeping position. 

Edge Support and Motion Isolation

On one hand, find a mattress with firm edge support that will prevent you from falling from the bed. On the other, if you want to sleep undisturbed, even if your partner decides to get up in the middle of the night to grab a snack, find a mattress with good motion isolation. Sound motion isolation will reduce the transition of movement. 

Temperature Regulation

When choosing the best mattress pillow top to fit your needs, pay attention to the temperature regulation. Do you tend to sleep hot or cold? Temperature regulation will depend on the materials. For example, memory foam tends to keep the heath in, while latex provides gentle cooling. 

Advantages and Disadvantages of Pillow Top Mattresses

Now that you learned what a top pillow mattress is, let’s focus on its advantages and disadvantages. 

Advantages:

  • Better cooling system
  • Lower price
  • Better motion isolation
  • More comfort and responsiveness 

Disadvantages:

  • Lower mattress durability
  • Not suitable for overweight individuals
  • People can experience problems with sagging

Wrapping Up

To find the best pillow top mattress to suit all your nocturnal needs, you need to pay attention to your weight, sleeping position, and material preference. The mattresses on our list come in many types, sizes, and forms, from soft and firm to innerspring and hybrid. 

If you’re a person that enjoys sleeping on a thick bundle of clouds, a pillow top mattress is something you simply must have to make those unattainable sweet dreams a reality.

FAQs

What is a pillow top mattress?

A pillow top mattress has an additional top layer that provides more comfort and better pressure relief, backed up with a strong innerspring foundation. It’s usually made of cotton or wool. Moreover, some are filled with latex or memory foam. 

In short, these mattresses provide the best of the two worlds—the bouncing feel of the traditional innerspring mattress, and the soft feel that can easily be described as sleeping on a fluffy cloud. 

What is the best pillow top mattress?

A good mattress needs to provide flawless comfort to the sleeper, focusing its features on pressure relief, strong support, and certified materials. We believe Saatva Classic mattresses have all that it takes to be the best in 2020. 

Their mattress has long durability, it’s made of eco-friendly materials, you can choose the firmness level, and it’s suitable for light and heavy sleepers. 

Can you flip a pillow top mattress?

The short answer to this question is no. If the mattress is not flippable, you shouldn’t flip it. Why? The layers on the top and bottom of the mattress are different. Moreover, flipping it on the wrong side could destroy the fabric and the mattress. 

However, if you want to expand its durability, you need to rotate it at least twice a year, but forget about flipping.

How long does a pillow top mattress last?

The average pillow top mattress durability is 7–10 years. However, you can extend the longevity of a pillow top mattress if you maintain it regularly. The materials will also play a significant role in the mattresses’ lifespan (e.g., some natural materials, like latex, can last more than others). 

To extend your mattress’ duration, you need to rotate it every three months, and please, shy away from jumping on it.

What is the best way to clean a pillow top mattress?

You need to clean your mattress every year, at least twice, and wash the sheets every week. This is especially important if you have a pet that likes to snuggle with you on the bed. To get rid of the dust, use a vacuum cleaner. For unpleasant smells, use water mixed with baking soda. And of course, don’t forget to use the “magical properties” of soap and water. 

In addition to that, you need to buy special sheets that will fit the mattress. The best sheets for a pillow top mattress need to be deep-pocketed. Before buying, be sure to measure your mattress’s depth and find the right size of the sheet (7–14 inches, 15 inches, or 16–22 inches). Furthermore, you will need to choose the sheet’s material. 

It would be best if you made this choice based on your personal preferences and your budget. Take into consideration that some materials cost more.

Is a pillow top mattress good for back pain?

Pillow top mattresses are meant to provide the sleeper with the best body support possible. As mentioned before, the additional top layer can be made of various materials. However, the best material that will help you ease back pain is memory foam. 

That said, any pillow top mattress filled with memory foam will be the right choice. Our pick is the Saatva Classic mattress. 

Are pillow top mattresses good for you?

Pillow top mattresses are better than typical mattresses because they provide additional support, responsiveness, as well as extra comfort. The prices of these mattresses are lower, and they usually provide better cooling systems. 

On the other hand, they have shorter durability, and you might experience sagging problems, which is why they are not recommended for overweight individuals. In addition to that, you’ll need to buy special sheets that will fit your mattress. With that in mind, we hope you’ll find the best pillow top mattress that will help you dream big.